I've seen this conversation all over. Let's hear our stories. Personally, I'm picking guys from our dynasty. Worst recruit: I'll let you guys guess who I'm going to say here. Biggest bust of all time, 5 star QB Brad Dailey. Had he been a 3 or 4 star, he wouldn't be here and Kelvin Kerr would be instead. Just ask YoungC about how awful he was. His drive against Miami his senior year was the most embarrassing thing ever. 3 passes, 0 completions. Bad, but if you had seen the in completions, you'd have laughed. They were so bad, I was laughing. And I'm usually flipping out over those types of throws. Only good thing about him was his running ability. Couldn't run people over, but he rarely fumbled. But for a 5 star, he should have known how to throw the ball. Best recruit: This one is also pretty obvious. Frank Johnson comes close, but he wasn't as great on the field as he could have been. It's easily Jake Rodriguez. 4 star athlete, coming in at 80 overall. Had maxed out potential, as his awareness went up 1 every 2 weeks (max it can). After 4 seasons, no redshirt, he left as a 95 overall and was a 2nd round pick on Madden, coming in at 75 overall. The guy also spotlighted on offense, and made huge plays in the slot. Easily my best recruit ever, minus the 99 speed WRs on NCAA 09.