Biggest Surprises and Busts from Recruiting? Well the annual, WTF from recruiting and 3 stars being better than 5 stars here are my early surprises both good and bad. The bad: Ricky Rogers - 4 star DT and #5 overall DT, comes in at a 75 OVR, yet my 3 star DT that I barely recruited comes in at 80 OVR. Ryan Johnson a 5 star recruit comes in at 78 OVR at CB, while Corey Graham a 4 star recruit comes in at 82 OVR. The good: Casey Thomas comes in at an 85 OVR and is just sick. My super fast Freshman WR comes in as an 86 OVR with 97 speed. Suffice it to say, Im happy.