Discussion in 'Team Management' started by BobJr, Jan 2, 2012.
Joe Flacco 90 OVR
Ryan Mallett 73 OVR
OLB Martez Wilson 73 OVR
Proposed on xfn
Malett is Bpot, Wilson is Apot but is 77ovr
Can we accept this?!
I know my opinion doesnt matter, but I dont think you would accept this from 2 other users...
It seems like the Ravens are giving up way too much to me. An elite starting NFL QB for a backup QB and a young aspiring OLB? Doesn't make sense to me.
Mallett will be my starter and martez will slide Inside once ray Lewis retires after this season.
Now u see why we need a commitee. All these trades have been ridiculous.
True, Keller you should assemble a committee of 5 like last time.
I voiced my thoughts on this in the chat room on XFN, I am okay with it, if the Bills add a little something to it.
Bills have to give up more. Elite starting QBs are hard to come by. This just isn't realistic at all
makes hard to know what will/won't work
The committee has NEVER worked.
If people want to put it to a committee thats fine, but I'm perfectly content with the way things are. The only person that approves my trades is Emmdot, I approve all others. I ask for opinions and help from others but ultimately the decision is mine. People that get trades vetoed obviously want things to change but if its a committee its not going to be any better. We've done this like 5 times already.
Need all of you to weigh in on this - as the first official action of the trade committee.
I gotta say the Bills need to sweeten it a little more, getting a top qb in his prime, and tho Wilson is a good piece, gotta add a little something more to me.
I can be on the trade committee if you need help.
Your getting a franchise QB for average QB and a a player that might progress to mid 80's in a couple years..
I thought the deadline was over lol. My feedback: Somewhat unrealistic, flacco and Mallet would probably never get traded but realizing this is a fictional league I could see it happening. I would probably say the ravens need a 6th or 7th too, but that isn't a deal breaker.
I thought the committee worked last time... It just stopped working when members of the committee stopped playing
I also agree, the Bills need to add some compensation
Bills I will add a 5th if that will appease the committee.
Feel free to weigh in unofficially - just didn't want to hand out extra work to you.
Up to you. Trade committee is pretty easy.
So updated trade:
That 5th adds nothing to the deal to me... This upcoming draft class is bad, I would be surprised if anyone actually keeps a rookie past the 4th round (we didnt in the GMFL)
Separate names with a comma.