A bit confused as to what matters more, overall accuracy or each individual accuracy. I haven't played much madden since the new QB ratings, so any insight would be much appreciated. The issue arose as I was presented with a dilemma in my OF draft. I had the #5 pick and needed a franchise QB after a simmed season. Which guy do you go with. Peter Newcomer, 83 overall. (6'3, 222). A potential 89 THP 65 ACC. 88 SAC 81 MAC 78 DAC. 87 SPD 90 ACC 92 AGI 86 SPIN 90 JUKE 76 CAR 83 INJ Ryan Kaiser, 84 overall (6'1,225). A potential. 94 THP 70 ACC. 86 SAC, 81 SAC, 69 DAC. 70 SPD 84 ACC 78 AGI 56 CAR 74 JUKE 54 SPIN 76 INJ Despite preferring a pocket QB, I pulled the trigger on Newcomer. Who would you have gone with and why? I feel as though the short, medium, and deep ratings are more important...but to be honest I really don't know. I don't think you can lose with either guy here.