For comparisons same, opening day rosters for this year only had like 7, 5* guys I think. And none of them were pitchers.
I'm pretty confused by one thing. Everybody is a 1.5 star for the Dugout file. but if I make a new game with opening day rosters, there's a TON of 1 star dudes.
Hmm, weird. The lowest I see in my MLB Quickstart is 1.5* as well. I bet it's a setting somewhere. So, I set it to "All player ratings are displayed relative to (Major League - but you can this to any other league)", and there are a few .5* and 1* players now. I want to say we have this setting enabled in the Dugout, but either NeuroticTruth or ty5oke would have to confirm.
That was my guess since I made sure to uncheck it. Would make sense why there are so many mid-level guys in that 2-3 star tier.