Discussion in 'Madden NFL Football' started by BlyGilmore, Aug 20, 2012.
Lots of defensive linemen and pass rushers. And a whole lot of BS.
Demarcus Ware a 99?
No one has more sacks then D-Ware since he entered the league. I see your a ShEli and the Gnats fan, but lets be honest with ourselves.
Not sure about Mario Williams being a 97. Hes been hurt the past 2 years and only had 1 really good year in his sophomore year. Since then its been downhill. Rather see Jason Babin or someone else at #10 but the ratings will change throughout the year anyways.
No G-men line?
No Steeler linebackers?
This means we should have all the ratings by the Early Release!
Um couple issues. no Nnamdi? No Suggs the DPOY?? No Ray Lewis I can kinda see but no suggs? Mularky pure and simple.
Nnamdi being on this list would be a complete joke after last year.
I think EA mixed up the years, some of these guy played at an elite level in 10-11 not 11-12 .......... Last year Revis wasn't that dude
TACKSOLOASTSACKFFFRYDSINTYDSAVGLNGTDPDSTFSTFYDSKB2011 Regular Season 52 41 11 0.0 0 0 0 4 184 46 100 1 21 1 3
I'm not saying he shouldn't be in the mid-90s but 99 for a guy who's almost a pure pass rusher? I mean he had 19.5 sacks last year and only 28 other tackles all season.
Or lets put it this way. Would anybody say Ware is a better all round OLB than Suggs? And yet Suggs isn't on this list and Ware is a 99.
No way Ware should be a 99. The top DE in the league shouldn't even be a 99. And Ware is not the top DE.
Reed & Troy yes Revis no .... he had established his self as a shut down guy but has fallen off since just like Asomugha. definitely not 99 ....... 95 maybe
yea sorry they got skewed like that. Id like to say Asante is still amazing.
Why wouldn't he be 99 Overall? He's the most dominate pass rusher in the league...lol
Haters my friend. Haters
After thinking about it Ratings don't hold the same marit as it used to... I wonder how it works if you where to put him in a different "system" troy in a man scheme, Revis in a zone blitz type defense Reed would def hold up in either ....... can't wait for madden
Ware is an animal and deserves every bit of that 99
As for Ray Lewis - dude can't even catch Paul Rudd ...
Have you seen the steelers one!?
D-Ware is the best defensive player in the NFL and he deserves a 99 overall. Mario Williams being a 97 is a joke because the Texans had the #1 defense in the NFL and won a playoff game w/o him. I would've had Suggs ranked ahead of Williams
Suggs should be on the list in the top 7 ATLEAST. Troy being #8? I feel that's low for him. Super Mario being #10? Too high. Only 1 true LB and 1 CB on here? I have more than 1 or 2 issues with this list. However, the main problem I think is that they have WAY too many players rated above 95. I think it's getting too saturated at the top end, they need to adjust the ratings scale. I feel EVERYONE on this list can be lowered 2-4 points (including Revis who should be around 95-96) and still be in the same position on the countdown. With Legends being in this game, they should have lowered these guys to give the Legends the 98's and 99's. Is EA trying to tell me that Mean Joe Greene is only 1 point above Justin Smith? Smith is good but come on, can he stand side by side with Mean Joe? And that Darelle Revis deserves the same rating as Deion Sanders, who btw has 99 speed rating and 100 man coverage?
Separate names with a comma.