Discussion in 'Madden NFL Football' started by BlyGilmore, Aug 6, 2012.
surprised Marshawn Lynch wasn't in there. 3rd in TDs and 7th in yards last year.
Buffalo's Fred Jackson probably missed out just because he didn't play 16 games. 5.5 yards a carry had him at the top of the league, with 93.4 yards a game third to just MJD and Foster.
I'm also surprised one bad year pushed Chris Johnson off the list.
List form they are:
1 MJD (97 ovr)
2 AP (97 ovr)
3 Foster (96 ovr)
4 Mccoy (95 ovr)
5 Ray Rice (95 ovr)
6 Forte (93 ovr)
7 Gore (92 ovr)
8 SJAX (92 ovr)
9 Jamal Charles (91 ovr)
10 M. Turner (91 ovr)
Not sure what to think yet.....
I think Fred Jackson needed to be on here. Man us unstoppable this year. Coming of injury I think Charles is a little high. Where is CJ?
I find it odd the Charles made top 10 and he didn't even smell grass last season. Mean while McFadden missed cut .... Missed 9 but still.
CJ2k should be 11 if he's not in top 10. Marshawn proved himself enough to be in the top 10 last year. With Charles being out most of last year you would think CJ or Lynch would hop into his spot. And MJD at #1 not so sure of. Sure he had over 1600 rush yds but he's the only one on that offense. He's a beast and deserves top 3, but I think Foster should be #1, MJD/Mccoy #2, AP #3 then down from there. Just my opinion.....
See i'd argue Stephen Jackson should be higher for a similar reason ... he was the only threat on that team last year and teams threw everything they could at him daring the Rams to throw.
List is laughable. Charles in top 10?? Hilarious. MJD 1, Amuzing. Turner in top 10?! Comical. Jackson not higher than 8?! LMAO funny
But the most remarkably laughable rating to this point is #3 Lasean McCoy. Funniest joke I've heard since the bunny fart joke.
Higher or Lower?
Michael Turner has no business on this list.
Don't worry fellas i just found out this list is based on helmet size .... Shit had me goin for a bit. So MJD has a 97 ovr sized helmet.
McCoy lower. Don't see how he's ahead of Ray Rice and Matt Forte. Not to mention S. Jackson.
Didn't he lead the league in rushing TDs last year, and have the the highest YPC?
I'd say he's pretty close to where he should be.
Forte and Rice are both comparable, and S-Jax is somewhat of a wildcard for me. It's hard to gauge just how good he is on such a crappy team. I guess we can say the same for MJD, but he kicks ass on a regular basis, so.....
Stats don't lie, 20 TDs (17 rushing), 4th in rushing yards...I'd say that's top 3 material...
Yea guess you're right. Didn't really realize he had that good of a year last year.
I think Matt Forte should be rank a little bit higher when your 60% of your teams offensive and your team is winning that makes a special kinda player he has that Boom (John Madden voice)
Plus he's still under 25, he's considered by most to be "THE" back you'd want to have for the next 5+ years. And not too many backs get comparisons to Barry Sanders
McCoy is Eagles' star on offense.. without him, they're nothing almost.
You could easily make the same point for both M. Forte and Ray Rice though. But I guess those 3 could all be flip flopped depending on personal opinion.
Hey I wanted to post this on the QB rating one but its locked so I'll post it here. Andrew Luck has 83 Spectacular Catch and 72 catching. RG3 has 65 Spec Catch and 67 Catching. If Im running wildcat its with Luck
Where is he at?
He was a steal last season for Miami. I think his rating will be around 85. Cant wait to see how he does in the new zone offense we are running
Somewhere constantly running out of bounds.
Separate names with a comma.